Wednesday, October 02, 2019

Dewey was a Racist (and that's not all)

Slate published a story about how the ALA has removed Melville Dewey's name from one of their most prestigious awards.  Since much of the behavior has been known since it was exhibited (by Dewey) it's a wonder the award was named for him in the first place.
In addition to Dewey’s sexism, the ALA resolution to drop his name, which was ratified unanimously by the organization’s governing council, also cited his anti-Semitism and racism. At a private club he owned on Lake Placid, Dewey did not allow Jews or blacks to become members or visitors. A club pamphlet read: “No one shall be received as a member or guest, against whom there is physical, moral, social or race objection. … It is found impracticable to make exceptions to Jews or others excluded, even when of unusual personal qualifications.” When news of the pamphlet became public, also in 1906, Dewey was forced to resign from his state library position. He defended himself, saying he had friends who were Jews, while also noting that a private club should be allowed to choose its members.
Slate article. 

And there's more:
Drabinski finds Dewey’s classification structure more offensive than any of his vices. “It’s all about white Christian power that has spread around the globe,” she said. “His personality pales in comparison to him as one individual dominating the structure of knowledge.”

Violet Fox, Dewey editor with the Online Computer Library Center, which owns the rights to the DDC, said the system is continuously updated, and editors are now “focusing on gender identity and sexual orientation as well as providing new options for classifying works about Indigenous peoples.”*

1 comment:

Inkling said...

Quote: Drabinski finds Dewey’s classification structure more offensive than any of his vices. “It’s all about white Christian power that has spread around the globe,” she said. “His personality pales in comparison to him as one individual dominating the structure of knowledge.”

And it that remark is not, in itself, rank bigotry, the what is? Legalized abortion illustrates all too well what lies at the heart of the progressive agenda and is infinitely worse that Dewey's little private club. As Justice Blackmun explained in the first paragraph of Roe v. Wade, the decision had "racial" and "eugenic" overtones. It would dispropotionate impact poor minorities and genetic flaws such as Downs Syndrome.